DeleteMe vs Incogni: An Honest 2026 Comparison
The short answer
DeleteMe and Incogni both remove your personal information from data brokers, but they trade differently. DeleteMe uses human-verified removals and a quarterly report at $129 a year, billed annually only. Incogni automates opt-outs across a wider broker roster for $7.99 a month billed annually ($95.88 a year). Choose DeleteMe for human oversight and a complex footprint; choose Incogni for lower cost and broader automated reach.
DeleteMe and Incogni are the two names people compare most when they finally decide to get their home address off the internet. Both are real, working services you can pay for today. They take almost opposite approaches to the same job, and the right pick depends on your budget, how complicated your history is, and whether you want a human in the loop. Prices below were checked on their own sites in July 2026; both companies change them, so confirm before you buy.
Full disclosure, because it matters when you read a comparison: we are building a data removal service of our own, and it has not launched. We have no reason to push you toward either of these, and every reason to describe them accurately, since anyone who buys on a claim we made up will remember it. What follows is how they actually differ.
The short version
DeleteMe is the older, human-assisted option. A person reviews and files your removals, you get a report every quarter, and it costs $129 a year for one person, billed annually. Incogni is the cheaper, fully automated option from Surfshark. Software sends the opt-out requests, a dashboard shows their status, and it costs $7.99 a month billed annually, which works out to $95.88 a year, with a month-to-month choice DeleteMe does not offer. Incogni reaches more brokers out of the box; DeleteMe puts a human on the awkward ones.
Pricing compared
| DeleteMe | Incogni | |
|---|---|---|
| Entry price | $129 / year (about $10.75 / month) | $7.99 / month billed annually ($95.88 / year) |
| Month-to-month | Not offered, annual only | Yes, at a higher monthly rate |
| Higher tier | 2 people $229 / yr; family of 4 $329 / yr | Unlimited $14.99 / mo billed annually ($179.88 / yr) |
| Family plan | Up to 4 people, $329 / year | Up to 5 people, from $15.99 / mo billed annually |
The headline gap is real: Incogni is roughly 25 to 40 percent cheaper for one person, depending on how you count DeleteMe's annual-only billing. If price is the deciding factor, that is the number that decides it. DeleteMe's family plan is the better value once you are covering four people, because Incogni's per-person cost stays closer to its single rate.
Coverage: how many brokers, and which
This is where the marketing numbers get slippery, so read them carefully. DeleteMe advertises coverage of 750 or more data brokers, but its standard individual plan actively removes from a smaller core roster, with the long tail handled on request or on higher tiers. Incogni sends deletion requests to a network of more than 420 brokers, including marketing aggregators, and its standard plan reaches all of them automatically rather than holding some back for an upsell.
For most people the practical result is that Incogni hits more brokers on day one, while DeleteMe's human team is better at the specific sites that reject automated requests. Neither covers every broker in existence, and no service does. If you want to see the full landscape they are working against, our data broker opt-out list names every major one, what it exposes, and how hard its form is.
Human verified vs fully automated
DeleteMe's pitch is that a real person handles your case, checks that a removal actually took, and re-files when a broker pushes back. That is genuinely valuable for the brokers that make opt-out deliberately painful, the ones that demand a notarized form or a phone call. The cost of that human work is the price and the cadence: you hear from them on a schedule, not the moment something changes.
Incogni's pitch is scale and speed through automation. It fires opt-out requests across its whole roster, invokes your rights under laws like CCPA on your behalf, and shows each request's status in a dashboard. The trade is that a request a broker rejects, or a site outside the roster, is where a purely automated pipeline runs out of road unless you are on the Unlimited tier, which adds custom removal requests. For a straightforward footprint that is a fine trade. For someone with five past addresses and two former names, the human review starts to earn its price.
Is Incogni or DeleteMe better?
Neither is better in the abstract; they are built for different buyers. Incogni is the better pick for most people who want the widest automated coverage at the lowest price and are comfortable reading a status dashboard. DeleteMe is the better pick if you specifically want a human managing the removals, you have a complicated history with many old names or addresses, or you value a written quarterly report you can hand to a spouse or a security team.
Is DeleteMe worth the money?
DeleteMe is worth $129 a year if your exposure is high or messy and you would rather a person owned the problem than manage it yourself. It has removed data for real customers since 2011, which is a longer track record than almost anyone in the category. If your footprint is simple and price is your main concern, you are paying a premium over Incogni for the human touch, and that premium is only worth it if you will actually use the reassurance it buys.
Does Incogni really work?
Yes, within the limits of any removal service. Incogni's automated requests do get listings taken down across its broker network, and independent 2026 testing generally credits it with broad reach and quick first results. What it cannot do, and does not claim to do, is guarantee a broker never re-lists you. Data brokers rebuild from fresh public records, so any service, Incogni included, is a subscription precisely because the work never finishes.
Can I just remove myself for free?
You can. Every broker these services use has a free opt-out form, and you are allowed to file them yourself. Budget around 20 hours for a thorough first pass across the major brokers, then a few hours every one to three months to catch reappearances. The reason people pay is not that the forms are secret; it is that filing and re-filing them across a hundred brokers, forever, is tedious in a way most people quit after the first afternoon. If you want to try, start with the free opt-out list and work top to bottom.
Which should you choose
Pick Incogni if you want the lowest price, the widest automated broker reach, a month-to-month option, or you are covering yourself and do not need a human reviewing each removal. Pick DeleteMe if you want a person managing a complex footprint, a written quarterly report, or the strongest track record in the category, and the higher annual price does not put you off. If you are protecting a whole family, price out DeleteMe's four-person plan against Incogni's five-person one with your actual numbers, because that is where the value flips.
We wrote longer, honest breakdowns of each service on their own: how we compare to DeleteMe and to Incogni, including where each of them beats what we are building. And if you want to understand what any of these services is actually doing on your behalf before you pay for it, our pricing page lays out the continuous-scanning approach we are taking and why the monitoring, not the first cleanup, is the part that earns the subscription.
Written by
The Dataremoval team, at Dataremoval. We are building an AI data removal service, which is why we spend our days reading data broker opt-out forms. Dataremoval is in early access and has no paying customers. Corrections to team@dataremoval.ai.
Keep reading
How to Remove Your Information From the Internet
The complete 2026 method: what is actually removable, the order to do it in, the brokers that matter most, and the parts nobody can delete for you.
Data Brokers Opt Out: The Complete Opt-Out List
Every major data broker, what it publishes about you, how hard the opt-out is, how long it takes, and a direct link to the real form.
Remove Personal Information From the Dark Web
The honest answer: you almost certainly cannot delete it. Here is what you can do instead, and why the services promising deletion are selling you monitoring.
Are Data Removal Services Worth It?
When paying for data removal actually pays off, when to do it yourself for free, and the one feature that decides whether the subscription is worth the money.
How to Remove Your Phone Number From the Internet
Where your number leaks from, the free order to clean it up in, the caller-ID apps most guides forget, and the calls you will still get afterward.
How Much Does Data Removal Cost?
Real 2026 numbers for DeleteMe, Incogni, and Optery, what family plans add, the free DIY route, and the single line item that actually justifies the yearly fee.